
Continuing with my slightly over personal, but honest stories, I decided to upload this; a letter I wrote to my abusive and absent father a couple of years ago. I haven’t seen my father for over eight years now, by choice. These were my thoughts, my feelings, my pain at this time. To this day, I haven’t sent this letter and I probably never will.
Picture above: My Dad and I in Dublin 1989
Dad,
I don’t know where to start, I don’t know where to end; I don’t even know what to say or how but for some reason I feel I need to do this, if at least to understand myself. I truly hope that you don’t hold this against me, use this against me even, and that you have the maturity and honesty to just except that this is your daughter being open with you for the first time in six years. Whether or not you are able to do that, I do not know for I do not know where you are in life, yet I suspect that it is not where you envisioned you would be.
If I wasn’t writing this to you now I would probably be tucked up in bed with a cigarette, watching DVDs such as ‘Six feet under’ or ‘French and Saunders’. It’s funny and also slightly sad that I’ve probably become a lot of the things you hate about the world. I smoke, I drink occasionally and I probably swear too much. I also have a partner who I have been with for nearly five years now, who is indeed female. I have fought with myself for many years because of this, not because I view it as wrong, but because the bible does, because my mother did, because society makes it clear that it’s not “the norm”. I feel assured though when I see relationships other than my own, perhaps even my own parents relationship and then realise that I have never known two people to be so close in all my life and I have never had someone love me so much or love someone so much in return. I don’t expect you to like the fact that I am with a woman, but I’m not seeking approval (I never have been the sort of person to need that) and I know that deep down somewhere you know how amazing and life changing a love like that can be. That is the important thing here. I also just want to make it clear that this is not Mum’s fault in any way, it is not something she has encouraged me into and it has taken her many years to even accept the fact that I love someone who is female. To me, love isn’t about gender and therefore I would never label myself into a corner and call myself “gay” or “straight”. I am neither; I am just a girl who is in love with another person. Love, like sexuality is fluid and it cannot be categorised and I do not wish it to be. I pray that you can at least understand this, even if you do not agree with it as I am sure you do not. Regardless of understanding, you’re right to disagree is certain, everyone deserves this right, but you’re vocalisation of what may be “disgust” or “disappointment” is not, you lost that right when you claimed disownment. Simply put, I don’t want to hear you’re negativity or narrow-mindedness on this matter. The world has come a long way since I was a child; the world no longer views same-sex relationships as “wrong”-In fact, it’s not something I keep from anyone, not from my University mates and not from my work colleagues. If my honesty and openness isolates people or makes these people feel un-comfortable then that is their issue, not my own-I will not live a lie for anyone.
I don’t want to talk about xxxxxx, xxxxxxxxx or Mum here because this letter is not about them and I would feel dis-loyal to them by giving an insight into their lives when you are not in touch with them anymore. Please except that I am not doing this to hurt you, but to save their hurt, for my family means everything to me. All I can say is that everything has changed. I am not the person you once knew, I am not the naïve little girl who thought she was so tough anymore, I am not the “happy go lucky” optimist that I once was. I have grown up, I have learnt about life the hard way; a lot of which I learnt from my father. To say my childhood screwed me up is an understatement to say the least, there’s not a day goes by where I don’t feel sad for the childhood I lost. The happy memories that I do have are sparse to say the least but there are a few. Namely, trips to the custom houses in xxxxxxx, to the museums that I visited at an early age and to late night sessions of ‘Star Trek’ re-runs in the living room. All of these I am thankful for, even though I would never dream of doing any of those things now.
I don’t know how to convey my feelings for you; I don’t even know what those feelings are. Anger, disappointment, fear and resentment for sure; but also a love and longing that can never be shifted no matter how much I try to suppress it. I was always “daddy’s little girl” no matter how close I was to Mum and even though I am extremely close to Mum now, I guess I always will be your daughter and I am like you in many ways. I guess this is why I understand; it is why I can live my life to an extent anyway, in happiness and not bitterness. It is why I feel a twinge of disloyalty to you when I feel anger towards you, to what you did; to the person you were throughout my childhood. I don’t think anyone else will ever understand why you were like you were, quite like I do; because I feel so many of the things you once did and maybe still do. Not the anger, not the violence, not the simple disregard for human life that you showed so much while I was growing up but the discontentment, the sadness, the loneliness, the desperation for truth, for understanding, for knowledge and the simple feeling that this life is not “real enough” for me. Everything seems so relative and meaningless when it comes to the crunch. I think so much of this internal pain and discontentment is because life is what you make it, and when you do not truly believe in pure and everlasting happiness, how you can be truly happy. I don’t think I have ever been truly happy and I honestly don’t think I am capable of such an emotion. Who is? What is true happiness anyway? Does anyone know? Happiness is relative to the person and therefore deeply personal and not easily understood.
I have battled for many years with clinical depression, I have been prescribed pills upon pills to help me cope with the feelings I have inside of me yet I refuse to become a slave to a “happy” chemical they say will take all the pain away. I am of the opinion that my bad experiences and the pain that I feel, makes me who I am and has moulded me into the person I am today. I don’t wish to get rid of the pain, for pain is what makes me alive, human, and real. I am, probably like you, a walking contradiction. I am still very much the happy-go-lucky confident and strong person that I was when I was growing up, yet I am also a broken person. A person who on days finds it hard to leave her flat and go out into the “big scary world” for fear of rejection, of pain, of hurt, of just “living”.
I am a person of mixed emotions, of mixed opinions, of mixed ideas, of thoughts and of character. There are no words to describe who I am, and even if there were, I would not know the words to tell you for I am still changing and learning more about myself everyday. These mixed emotions also relate to how I feel about my childhood, how I feel about you, my father. There are days that I wish I had had as a child, a better father, a father who could love me the way I wanted him too, a father who would not hurt me like mine did, a father who was not hurting so much himself and was therefore able to save me from the hurt. There is though, a lot of compassion and understanding in this and I would never say I hated you; just that I hated what you did. I see only too clearly from my own experiences and mistakes how easy it is to lose yourself and to become something you do not want to be. I do not wish un-happiness upon you like so many others may do, all I wish for you is that you could really truly see how wrong you were and that you could be more of the person you could have been.
I am always reminded of a school assembly I attended when the school teacher at xxxxxx held up a white A4 piece of paper with a tiny black dot on it and asked what we saw. Of course, everyone saw only a black dot and did not comment on the fact that we actually saw a large piece of white paper with a small black dot on it. The black dot represented the bad things we did, the mistakes. No-body noticed the white of the paper; only the black dot that lay upon it. I think his point was that mistakes can’t be changed and people only too easily forget the good stuff and can only focus only the “bad”, the mistakes. This is most people’s memory of the things that you did. The good stuff is somehow erased from the un-conscious and nothing but mistakes are left. This is not how I view you and perhaps that makes me a little naive but I prefer to think of a father who did love me and who did do things right, but sometimes got it very, very wrong. Un-fortunately the black spot cannot be forgotten or forgiven or even justified, but it can be understood and you are lucky enough to have a daughter who can see the bigger picture and who can relate to how easily it is to screw up.
I don’t know what else to say except that I am happy with who I am and the person I have become and a lot of that is to do with my childhood. I had rules, I had an education and I had two parents who I do feel loved and still do love me even if they didn’t always show that to me. There is no self pity involved where my childhood is concerned. A lot of people would probably view my childhood as a tragedy, but I do not. The emotional hurt that was inflicted upon me at an early age has made me into the strong and self asserted person that I am today. Many people have had it far worse than I did and I thank God that I have been able to learn from my parents mistakes and come through the other side, with lessons learnt. For I know that I will never make the same mistakes with my own children when I have them, and that they will benefit from the lessons I have learned because of my own childhood. Although I am a person with ongoing issues and hurts, I have become a person that is respected for my opinions, for my character and for my honesty.
At seventeen I fell in love and experienced the best thing that has ever happened to me. At twenty I became a published writer of poetry and experienced an amazing sense of self achievement and happiness because I was understood, no matter how messed up I may be. Most of all, I have to be thankful for the ambition that you instilled in me at a very early age, for this drive has helped me through so many things not to mention passing my a-levels, getting into an amazing university and studying the things I enjoy so much. I started off down the route that probably won’t surprise you, ‘Information Technology’, but much to my own amazement I have now been given the opportunity to study the things that are far more important, Philosophy and Psychology. I have just finished my second year of an honours degree in ‘Applied Psychology’ which is a lot of hard work but is also very gratifying and interesting. I have no particular aim in life; only that I can fulfil my dreams, be loved and love in return. All of which, I am doing and hopefully I will continue to do. Of course, this is all most people can ever hope to achieve and I feel completely blessed to have a mother that supports me in everything I do; without her I would be nothing.
I wish you knew me Dad, I wish you had the opportunity to be proud of me as I hope you would be. There is not a day that goes by where I don’t regret the fact that we do not have a relationship because deep down I am still a scared little girl who so desperately wants the love of not only her mother, but her father; I’m just not sure that you are able right now (or ever will be) to give me the kind of love that I so deeply crave or the kind of relationship that every child should have the right too with their father. I trust that you understand what I am saying here; you yourself have suffered because of your relationship or non-relationship with your father. I just hope that you can once and for all take what I am saying here onboard and take it in the context and manner that it is intended, even if I perhaps do not completely understand it myself. I must also add that it saddens me deeply that I never received a card for my 18th or for my 21st birthday but I can understand the hurt and rejection you must have felt when I stated that I never wanted to have any contact with you. I’m not sure if I would have reacted in the same way you did if the roles were reversed, for I know only too well how much it hurt. However, that cannot be un-done now and in all honesty; it would take a lot more than that to break me for I know that I am of value even if you do not believe that to be true.
I do not know where you are in life, where you are as a person or if you even think of me at all but I am re-assured by the knowledge that you did once love me, that I am loved now by others and that I can remember times where you were the father that I wanted you to be. I don’t want to hurt anymore and I wish the same for you. I hope you have tasted a least a drop of happiness in our time apart and I pray that we both do in the future.
Emma